High Court of Justiciary Trial Papers - Search ResultHelp

TitleTrial papers relating to Andrew May, John Fitzclarence, James McCabe
NameAndrew May
RoleAccused
Age25
Approx Birth Year1831
CrimeTheft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the person
Crime LocationPrestonfield House, Duddingston, Edinburgh
Trial Date6 November 1856
Trial LocationEdinburgh
VerdictGuilty
SentenceTransportation - Life
Previous ConvictionsTheft - Glasgow police court, 1 June 1852
NRS ReferenceJC26/1856/379
NotesCriminal letters.
List of Accused
Name and DesignationAgeBirthplaceCrime  
Andrew May25FifeTheft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the personPerson Details
Name Andrew May
Age 25
Birthplace Fife
Crime Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the person
Person Details
James McCabe alias Thompson alias McNeil32IrelandTheft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the personPerson Details
Name James McCabe alias Thompson alias McNeil
Age 32
Birthplace Ireland
Crime Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the person
Person Details
John Fitzclarence alias O'Donnel24Dublin, IrelandTheft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the personPerson Details
Name John Fitzclarence alias O'Donnel
Age 24
Birthplace Dublin, Ireland
Crime Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the person
Person Details
Victim(s)
Name and DesignationAgeBirthplaceCrime  
James Patterson, butler to Lady Harriet Dick Cunyngham, Prestonfield House, Duddingston, Edinburgh  Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the personPerson Details
Name James Patterson, butler to Lady Harriet Dick Cunyngham, Prestonfield House, Duddingston, Edinburgh
Age
Birthplace
Crime Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the person
Person Details
James Scott, coachman to Mary Anne Dick Cunyngham, Prestonfield House, Duddingston, Edinburgh  Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the personPerson Details
Name James Scott, coachman to Mary Anne Dick Cunyngham, Prestonfield House, Duddingston, Edinburgh
Age
Birthplace
Crime Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the person
Person Details
Lady Harriet Dick Cunyngham, relict (widow) of Sir Robert Keith Dick Cunyngham, Prestonfield House, Duddingston, Edinburgh  Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the personPerson Details
Name Lady Harriet Dick Cunyngham, relict (widow) of Sir Robert Keith Dick Cunyngham, Prestonfield House, Duddingston, Edinburgh
Age
Birthplace
Crime Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the person
Person Details
Mary Anne Dick Cunyngham, daughter of Lady Harriet Dick Cunyngham, Prestonfield House, Duddingston, Edinburgh  Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the personPerson Details
Name Mary Anne Dick Cunyngham, daughter of Lady Harriet Dick Cunyngham, Prestonfield House, Duddingston, Edinburgh
Age
Birthplace
Crime Theft by housebreaking, habit and repute, and previous conviction, and assault to the effusion of blood and serious injury of the person
Person Details


Order a Copy of the Precognition, Trial Papers and Trial Minutes

These records can help you trace your family tree and understand the lives of your ancestors. Order a copy of the Precognition, Trial Papers and Trial Minutes for £45.00. Watch our video to find out what you will receive.

The records of the High Court are truly amazing and are one of the most comprehensive sources relating to your family you are likely to find. The witness statements are fascinating and give us a glimpse into our past. To find out more about these wonderful documents visit our Learning Zone.

There are three main sets of records relating to each trial and we can help you access these by providing high quality images for a small research fee. You can either order all three (recommended) or you can order the trial papers alone (see below). If you have any questions please contact us and we can advise you.

The precognition was made before the trial and may contain information not used at trial. The indictment is usually contained in the precognition papers and this will give you an outline of the facts of the case, but the main part of the precognition is normally made up of detailed witness statements.

The trial papers or ‘High Court of Justiciary Trial Papers’ contain some of the same information that you will find in the precognition, but you will also find additional information. Any paper evidence supplied to the court such as maps etc. will be contained in these records. You can see an example of one of the exciting items we found in our Learning Zone.

The minute book is the third record we recommend searching. Although briefer than the precognition and trial papers, this record tells you what happened on the day(s) of the trial and the outcome of the case, it completes the picture.

For the research fee of £45 we will copy all three of these records for you (please note that if the case is particularly extensive we will limit the research time to 80 minutes). By clicking 'Add to Cart', you will place an order for this entry in your PayPal 'Shopping Cart'. There is a link to the Shopping Cart at the foot of each page on the site so that you can review or amend your order at any time.

As this involves a trip to the National Records of Scotland in Edinburgh it can take a few weeks to process your order. We usually try to complete all orders within 4 weeks.

From time to time the National Records of Scotland withdraws access to original documents. For example, sometimes the documents are too fragile to be handled. If for any reason this record cannot be produced for us we will provide a full refund and an explanation of why we can’t access the original record.


Order a Copy of the High Court Trial Papers (only)

- £25

For the research fee of £25 we will locate and copy the trial papers for you (please note if the case is particularly extensive, we may limit the copying time to 40 minutes, but this is unusual). By clicking 'Add to Cart', you will place an order for this entry in your PayPal 'Shopping Cart'. There is a link to the Shopping Cart at the foot of each page on the site so that you can review or amend your order at any time.

As this involves a trip to the National Records of Scotland in Edinburgh it can take a few weeks to process your order. We usually try to complete all orders within 4 weeks.

From time to time the National Records of Scotland withdraws access to original documents. For example, sometimes the documents are too fragile to be handled. If for any reason this record cannot be produced for us we will provide a full refund and an explanation of why we can’t access the original record.


Do You Have a Question?

If you are not sure if this is the item you need or of you have another question, email our genealogist Emma Maxwell, and she will do all she can to help.

We also have a Facebook group where you can learn more about the records that we are indexing.

Source Citation
'High Court of Justiciary Trial Papers', NRS Reference JC26/1856/379; Index, Scottish Indexes (https://www.scottishindexes.com/jcdetail.aspx?jcid=1856379&pid=185637901: accessed 06 Jan 2025); Original Source: National Records of Scotland, Edinburgh, Scotland.

Index - Copyright Graham Maxwell 2018-2023.
High Court of Justiciary Records - National Records of Scotland catalogue: Crown copyright.


This is a search result from our Criminal Records index. To find out more about this record set, please see our help page.